OM 606 crankshaft grinding - Printable Version

OM 606 crankshaft grinding - Printable Version

+- STD (https://www.superturbodiesel.com/std)
+-- Forum: Tuning (https://www.superturbodiesel.com/std/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Forum: Engine (https://www.superturbodiesel.com/std/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: OM 606 crankshaft grinding (/showthread.php?tid=8190)

OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 01-26-2019

I am repairing a 606 that dropped a prechamber. I am having it balanced due to boring it and new pistons. The shop doing the balancing was grinding some material off the crank for balance and slipped and hit one of the journals. He want's to have the crank ground .010 under to repair it.
I am not a fan of ground cranks, has anyone had a 606 ground, is it acceptable to do on 606 cranks?

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - barrote - 01-27-2019

Mb cranks are like any other...
Repair can be done as low as u have journal sleeves to fit in.
I just don't know how easy is to get a .10 repair cap in there.
But i guess the ticker MB cap is around that value.
If is a crack on a main just polish it... no need to repair the the journal that deep.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - German Diesel - 01-27-2019

Hi,

do you sure that you have to make something with the crankshaft?

I have totally rebuild an OM606 turbo, and the crank, looks like new, i have messure it, it was like a new one.
The engine has run minimum 400.000km.

Here some pictures:

[Image: 34935069rn.jpg]

Steffen

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - baldur - 01-27-2019

Full of fail. You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons. It's simply not possible.
But as for journal grinding, yes you can grind journals on a crank that has not had a bearing spun on it. Crankshafts that have had a bearing overheat lose their heat treat.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 01-27-2019

(01-27-2019, 07:49 AM)baldur Full of fail. You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons. It's simply not possible.
But as for journal grinding, yes you can grind journals on a crank that has not had a bearing spun on it. Crankshafts that have had a bearing overheat lose their heat treat.

Were balancing the whole engine, pistons , crankshaft, rods and flywheel and balancer.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 01-27-2019

(01-27-2019, 05:02 AM)barrote Mb cranks are like any other...
Repair can be done as low as u have journal sleeves to fit in.
I just don't know how easy is to get a .10 repair cap in there.
But i guess the ticker MB cap is around that value.
If is a crack on a main just polish it... no need to repair the the journal that deep.

I haven't seen the damage to the crank yet. He said he hit it with a grinder wheel taking some balance material off. I agree if it is a nick polish it and let the oil fill it in.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - Turbo - 01-27-2019

(01-27-2019, 07:49 AM)baldur Full of fail. You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons. It's simply not possible.
But as for journal grinding, yes you can grind journals on a crank that has not had a bearing spun on it. Crankshafts that have had a bearing overheat lose their heat treat.

you said -"You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons."
why not
are these guys below wrong?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANWBEY8U6K0

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - baldur - 01-27-2019

(01-27-2019, 03:14 PM)Turbo
(01-27-2019, 07:49 AM)baldur Full of fail. You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons. It's simply not possible.
But as for journal grinding, yes you can grind journals on a crank that has not had a bearing spun on it. Crankshafts that have had a bearing overheat lose their heat treat.
you said -"You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons."
why not
are these guys below wrong?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANWBEY8U6K0

Inline 6 or inline 4 cranks have pistons moving up and down on one axis only. You cannot balance up and down motion by anything you do with the crankshaft. This isn't like a V8 engine where you have two axis of piston motion that are perpendicular, so these guys are right, but if you apply the same technique to an inline engine you are wrong.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 01-27-2019

(01-27-2019, 05:54 PM)baldur
(01-27-2019, 03:14 PM)Turbo
(01-27-2019, 07:49 AM)baldur Full of fail. You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons. It's simply not possible.
But as for journal grinding, yes you can grind journals on a crank that has not had a bearing spun on it. Crankshafts that have had a bearing overheat lose their heat treat.
you said -"You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons."
why not
are these guys below wrong?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANWBEY8U6K0

Inline 6 or inline 4 cranks have pistons moving up and down on one axis only. You cannot balance up and down motion by anything you do with the crankshaft. This isn't like a V8 engine where you have two axis of piston motion that are perpendicular, so these guys are right, but if you apply the same technique to an inline engine you are wrong.

You are not balancing the up and down motion with the crank. Your are balancing the rotating mass of the crankshaft. The pistons are balanced by their weight as well as the rods big end and small end. It doesn't matter if it is an inline or opposed cylinder. Balancing is balancing.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - baldur - 01-28-2019

(01-27-2019, 10:17 PM)zeeman
(01-27-2019, 05:54 PM)baldur
(01-27-2019, 03:14 PM)Turbo you said -"You don't rebalance an inline 6 crankshaft for the weight of the pistons."
why not
are these guys below wrong?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANWBEY8U6K0

Inline 6 or inline 4 cranks have pistons moving up and down on one axis only. You cannot balance up and down motion by anything you do with the crankshaft. This isn't like a V8 engine where you have two axis of piston motion that are perpendicular, so these guys are right, but if you apply the same technique to an inline engine you are wrong.
You are not balancing the up and down motion with the crank. Your are balancing the rotating mass of the crankshaft. The pistons are balanced by their weight as well as the rods big end and small end. It doesn't matter if it is an inline or opposed cylinder. Balancing is balancing.

Except there's an even number of evenly spaced rotating masses attached to the crank. You do not bob weight balance a crank for an inline 6 engine, you balance the crank by itself and you balance the rods by themselves.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 01-28-2019

(01-28-2019, 08:09 AM)baldur
(01-27-2019, 10:17 PM)zeeman
(01-27-2019, 05:54 PM)baldur Inline 6 or inline 4 cranks have pistons moving up and down on one axis only. You cannot balance up and down motion by anything you do with the crankshaft. This isn't like a V8 engine where you have two axis of piston motion that are perpendicular, so these guys are right, but if you apply the same technique to an inline engine you are wrong.
You are not balancing the up and down motion with the crank. Your are balancing the rotating mass of the crankshaft. The pistons are balanced by their weight as well as the rods big end and small end. It doesn't matter if it is an inline or opposed cylinder. Balancing is balancing.
Except there's an even number of evenly spaced rotating masses attached to the crank. You do not bob weight balance a crank for an inline 6 engine, you balance the crank by itself and you balance the rods by themselves.

I think the balancer is quite aware of that. What is your point?

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - baldur - 01-29-2019

(01-28-2019, 07:55 PM)zeeman
(01-28-2019, 08:09 AM)baldur
(01-27-2019, 10:17 PM)zeeman You are not balancing the up and down motion with the crank. Your are balancing the rotating mass of the crankshaft. The pistons are balanced by their weight as well as the rods big end and small end. It doesn't matter if it is an inline or opposed cylinder. Balancing is balancing.
Except there's an even number of evenly spaced rotating masses attached to the crank. You do not bob weight balance a crank for an inline 6 engine, you balance the crank by itself and you balance the rods by themselves.

I think the balancer is quite aware of that. What is your point?

My point is that changing pistons or rods does not put an inline 6 crankshaft out of balance.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 01-29-2019

(01-29-2019, 06:36 AM)baldur
(01-28-2019, 07:55 PM)zeeman
(01-28-2019, 08:09 AM)baldur Except there's an even number of evenly spaced rotating masses attached to the crank. You do not bob weight balance a crank for an inline 6 engine, you balance the crank by itself and you balance the rods by themselves.

I think the balancer is quite aware of that. What is your point?

My point is that changing pistons or rods does not put an inline 6 crankshaft out of balance.

I guess I am not being clear, we are balancing the crank as well as the pistons which were replaced, as well as the rods to improve the factory balance.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - German Diesel - 01-30-2019

Hi,
I dont understand it. Do you mean that, if i change a piston or a rod, i have to balance the Crankshaft. i also think so, if the piston has an other weigth.

But i just have changed the the piston rings and the friction bearings. The Pistons get a new plating. The rest was in so good condition i dont want to change it.

So, everything is good (:

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - barrote - 01-30-2019

No no no
What baldur was saying is that inline 6 and 4 are inherently stable, lets say they are balanced engines as oposed to L3 L5 L7 V4 V6 V8 especially.
So once crank is built it need dinamic balance of crank alone, then when u add rods and pistons this need to be iqual to maintain balance.
On the other hand american style v6 and v8 without balancer shafts need to be balanced and very often a vibration damper is needed.
Our 6 cyl are ok as long u respect piston and crank iqual weights.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - Keino - 01-30-2019

Hope you dont mind my input here.

I recently ran my om617.952 "dry" on oil due to a burst oil feeding to the turbo. (7.5mm pump and Borgwarner s200g)

The crank was damaged aswell as 2 piston rods nr 2 and 4

Crank is being grinded down and heat treated @ shop and 0.25mm oversized bearings will be installed.

I bought 2 used rods in good condition. But after weighing them i found out that the 2 new ones are slightly lighter.

The rods in order weighs as such
No 1 895gram
No 2 885gram (from other engine)
No 3 895gram
No 4 885-890gram (from other engine) The weighing machine was moving back and forth between 885 and 890
No 5 900gram

The 2 piston rods that went bad are both 900

Any idea how bad this is? Should i grind some of the heavier ones to make them more equal? Or reweigh them with the piston attached?

Thanks for any input.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - NZScott - 01-30-2019

In the 617 factory manual there's a procedure of where to grind off material from rods (well I remember reading some manual about it once)/
(also has the max tolerance for weight difference)

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - Keino - 01-31-2019

(01-30-2019, 11:40 PM)NZScott In the 617 factory manual there's a procedure of where to grind off material from rods (well I remember reading some manual about it once)/
(also has the max tolerance for weight difference)

Read in the haynes book but couldn't find it there. =(

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 02-03-2019

(01-31-2019, 09:49 AM)Keino
(01-30-2019, 11:40 PM)NZScott In the 617 factory manual there's a procedure of where to grind off material from rods (well I remember reading some manual about it once)/
(also has the max tolerance for weight difference)

Read in the haynes book but couldn't find it there. =(

Balancing is best done by a shop that specializes in balancing. There is a right and wrong way to do this. And there is equipment that a shop has that we don't normally have. The OM 617 engines I have had balanced have been way off from the factory.

This goes true with the OM 606 engine as well, they are better then the OM 617 for balance but are still not as good as they could be.

And no you don't have to balance the crankshaft if you are just replacing a piston or con rod, but have the set of whatever you are replacing matched balanced.

My theory is you have it torn down this far why not balance the whole thing, balancing is fairly reasonable. My balancer tries to keep everything within a 1-2 grams if possible.

I spoke to F-tune and they highly recommend balancing if you have a OM 606 torn down.
Just my thoughts.

RE: OM 606 crankshaft grinding - zeeman - 02-03-2019

(01-30-2019, 11:40 PM)NZScott In the 617 factory manual there's a procedure of where to grind off material from rods (well I remember reading some manual about it once)/
(also has the max tolerance for weight difference)

One thing to consider is the balancing spects back in the 80's were set to what their machines could do then, we have much better equipment now to be more accurate.